Bloggers will be familiar with the fourfold sense of scripture in medieval hermeneutics: the literal sense (plain, historical), the allegorical sense (ecclesiastical), the tropological sense (moral), and the anagogical sense (eschatological). Here is an allegorical interpretation of the birth of Jesus - a bit of fun with Christian denominations.
The Angels: Methodists - of course - what with all that interminable singing and praising.
The Shepherds: Baptists - simple folk, no frills - and they practice sheep-dipping.
The Wise Men: Orthodox - they’re from the East - and all that gold and incense.
(Alternatively) The Kings - Anglicans, in particular, the Church of England - establishment, pomp and circumstance - not to mention that they strut around like they own the place!
Mary: Roman Catholics - who else?
Joseph: Reformed - because Joseph is the real hero of the piece, who keeps his son safe, who is patient with Mary - and he’s a dreamer. Oh, and because Karl Barth found him to be more appropriate than Mary as protector (et exemplar) ecclesiae.
The Farm Animals: Charismatics - it’s their strange noises, bellowing like oxen and braying like donkeys.
The Innkeeper: The Religious Right - who run the church like a hotel where the posh suites go to the rich and powerful - but “no room” for Christ.
Have a cool Yule!
Kim
{ 9 comments… read them below or add one }
Ben Myers 12.20.06 at 12:03 pm
One important addition:
The Star: A celebrity pastor of a wealthy mega-church, with glistening smile and sparkling Rolex. Sure, Jesus is the Lord — but this guy’s the star!
Jonathan Marlowe 12.20.06 at 4:26 pm
My vote for Herod would be John Shelby Spong — he hates the virgin birth.
Ian McKenzie 12.20.06 at 5:55 pm
All the trumpet playing angels have left the Methodists and joined a Salvation Army band.
Kim 12.20.06 at 6:00 pm
Ben, Jonathan, Ian,
Thanks for your brilliant additions!
David Faulkner 12.20.06 at 7:50 pm
If Kenneth Bailey is to be believed, there is no innkeeper anyway, since Jesus was probably not born at the back of an inn but the back of a house, following middle eastern hospitality culture. So there you go - the Religious Right gone in one fell swoop!
Paul 12.20.06 at 8:34 pm
Would the Fourth Wise Man be the Anglo-Catholics, somewhat left behind?
DH 12.20.06 at 9:39 pm
Paul no the ones that were “Left Behind” were the Pharisee’s who didn’t Believe that Jesus was God.
DH 12.20.06 at 9:41 pm
Just being funny andpartly serious at the same time. This wasn’t a correction of Paul but another humorous way at looking at those whose “let Salvation pass them by” and thus were “Left Behind” and will be at the resurrection “Left Behind”.
JamesC 12.21.06 at 10:24 am
aw… bless the anglo-catholics… and i even feel sorry for shelby spong… don’t worry it won’t last long before the wonder of christmas passes by and i go back to being my evangelical self again.