An Allegorical Interpretation of the Birth of Jesus

by Kim on December 20, 2006

Bloggers will be familiar with the fourfold sense of scripture in medieval hermeneutics: the literal sense (plain, historical), the allegorical sense (ecclesiastical), the tropological sense (moral), and the anagogical sense (eschatological). Here is an allegorical interpretation of the birth of Jesus - a bit of fun with Christian denominations.

The Angels: Methodists - of course - what with all that interminable singing and praising.

The Shepherds: Baptists - simple folk, no frills - and they practice sheep-dipping.

The Wise Men: Orthodox - they’re from the East - and all that gold and incense.

(Alternatively) The Kings - Anglicans, in particular, the Church of England - establishment, pomp and circumstance - not to mention that they strut around like they own the place!

Mary: Roman Catholics - who else?

Joseph: Reformed - because Joseph is the real hero of the piece, who keeps his son safe, who is patient with Mary - and he’s a dreamer. Oh, and because Karl Barth found him to be more appropriate than Mary as protector (et exemplar) ecclesiae.

The Farm Animals: Charismatics - it’s their strange noises, bellowing like oxen and braying like donkeys.

The Innkeeper: The Religious Right - who run the church like a hotel where the posh suites go to the rich and powerful - but “no room” for Christ.

Have a cool Yule!
Kim

{ 9 comments… read them below or add one }

1

Ben Myers 12.20.06 at 12:03 pm

One important addition:

The Star: A celebrity pastor of a wealthy mega-church, with glistening smile and sparkling Rolex. Sure, Jesus is the Lord — but this guy’s the star!

2

Jonathan Marlowe 12.20.06 at 4:26 pm

My vote for Herod would be John Shelby Spong — he hates the virgin birth.

3

Ian McKenzie 12.20.06 at 5:55 pm

All the trumpet playing angels have left the Methodists and joined a Salvation Army band. ;)

4

Kim 12.20.06 at 6:00 pm

Ben, Jonathan, Ian,

Thanks for your brilliant additions!

5

David Faulkner 12.20.06 at 7:50 pm

If Kenneth Bailey is to be believed, there is no innkeeper anyway, since Jesus was probably not born at the back of an inn but the back of a house, following middle eastern hospitality culture. So there you go - the Religious Right gone in one fell swoop!

6

Paul 12.20.06 at 8:34 pm

Would the Fourth Wise Man be the Anglo-Catholics, somewhat left behind?

7

DH 12.20.06 at 9:39 pm

Paul no the ones that were “Left Behind” were the Pharisee’s who didn’t Believe that Jesus was God.

8

DH 12.20.06 at 9:41 pm

Just being funny andpartly serious at the same time. This wasn’t a correction of Paul but another humorous way at looking at those whose “let Salvation pass them by” and thus were “Left Behind” and will be at the resurrection “Left Behind”.

9

JamesC 12.21.06 at 10:24 am

aw… bless the anglo-catholics… and i even feel sorry for shelby spong… don’t worry it won’t last long before the wonder of christmas passes by and i go back to being my evangelical self again.

Leave a Comment

You can use these HTML tags and attributes: <a href="" title=""> <abbr title=""> <acronym title=""> <b> <blockquote cite=""> <cite> <code> <del datetime=""> <em> <i> <q cite=""> <strike> <strong>