There are some pretty awful prayers out there. The Sinner’s Prayer is an awful prayer for all sorts of reasons that have been well rehearsed, not least by evangelicals, particularly the version where, as the climax to a manna-back guaranteed four-part plan of salvation, you say it on the Naughty Step (otherwise known as the Anxious Seat). The Prayer of Jabez is another God-awful prayer. I think of it as the Thirty Days Mind-Loss Manifest Destiny Prayer: daily reiteration for a month of the petition “enlarge my border” and Bingo! – you’re a soteriological imperialist.
But the most awful prayer of all has got to be the Justwanna Prayer. This is a corporate prayer. It works best when you form a circle (facing inwards) and sit slouching forward, in something like the position one is told to assume by flight attendants in case of a plane crash. (Holding hands is optional, particularly among hormone-rich adolescents who might thereby be sexually distracted). Then off goes one of the group: “Father, I/we justwanna praise you for this, and justwanna thank you for that, and justwanna ask you for the other thing.” Why is this so awful?
One reason is the brain-numbing heart-sinking spirit-sapping repetition of the phrase, as it is invariably picked up and echoed by the next pray-er, and then the one after that, and then the one after that, … “world without end”. Often the initial vocative “Father” is also religiously repeated, as if God might suddenly forget his paternal identity and think he’s a Second Cousin.
What makes the repetition even worse is that the “justwanna” is grammatically redundant. Why “we justwanna thank you”? Why not, simply, “we thank you”? What work does the “justwanna” do? Syntactically, none whatsoever. It should be struck out with a red prayer pen.
Actually, however, the “justwanna” does do some work – work, however that makes you justwanna puke. It goes with the body-language of the slouch. You might even call this the Uriah Heap Prayer for its “umbleness”. Humility? No, false humility, because the obsequiousness suggests (a) that we are not really asking for all that much, so it ill behoves God not to give us what we ask for, unless (b) we justwanna do great things for God, like have a mission and save the atheists, Muslims, and lost folk at St. Gargoyle’s from eternal, painful, if pointless, perdition, in which case, still with hand-wringing self-abasement, we give God alone the glory.
Finally, one might ask why this atrocious prayer has such staying power. The answer is not far to seek (apart from sheer inertia). The Justwanna Prayer is a shibboleth. It’s the badge that you are a certain kind of Christian, the saved kind of Christian. It’s a sort of Masonic handshake: those who don’t punctuate their prayers with “justwanna” are not part of the guild, and must either be cold-shouldered or initiated into this arcane rite. Perhaps by first saying the Sinner’s Prayer or the Prayer of Jabez.
{ 10 comments… read them below or add one }
Paul 08.31.10 at 8:20 pm
I really do just want to thank you for this Kim. I often wonder why those who “Just want to praise you, Lord” don’t get on and praise, worship, bless, or whatever they just want to do.
dh 08.31.10 at 10:29 pm
Well folks. I DO believe that the people who just want to praise the Lord DO go on and praise, worship, bless, etc. Why do people have to criticize how people pray if it doesn’t go against Scripture? Why criticize the sinners prayer when many people have truly given their entire lives to Christ and whose lives have been changed forever including myself? Have some done it out of some other motive? yes but any prayer like that has that potential and that is not based on the prayer itself.
“do great things for God, like have a mission and save the atheists, Muslims, and lost folk at St. Gargoyle’s from eternal, painful, if pointless, perdition, in which case (c), of course, we give God alone the glory.” Nothing wrong with this.
“Except a man be Born Again he cannot see the Kingdom of God.” “If you confess with your mouth the Lord Jesus and Believe in your heart that God has risen from the dead you shall be saved.” “A fool says in his heart there is no God.” “Thou shalt have no other gods before Me.” “He that has the son has life. He that has not the Son has not life.”
Pam 08.31.10 at 11:36 pm
Great post, Kim - I know just what you’re talking about. That awful song “Girls Justwanna Have Fun” also comes to mind.
During the last few weeks I’ve been teaching my scripture class (kindergarten age 5-6 years) the Lord’s Prayer, but in simpler language on the theme “Thank you, Please, Sorry”. I love this time with the kids. btw, I’m praying for the lost folk at St. Gargoyle’s!
Tim Chesterton 09.01.10 at 12:22 am
Reminds me of a story I heard Noel Stookey tell once, about the language they speak on airlines: “They say, ‘We’d like to welcome you aboard flight 520 to New York’ - but they never do!”
Tony Buglass 09.01.10 at 12:35 pm
The function of “just” or “justwanna” in such praying is mental punctuation, slowing down the mouth to give the brain a chance to catch up. It happens when people begin to speak without knowing where the sentence is going to go - other such punctuations include “like” and “you know”.
When I was a prison chaplain, the inmates’ speech was liberally peppered with f*****ng and b***** - for the same reason: they weren’t angry or swearing, they were just slowing the mouth down to allow the brain a chance to work out where it was being taken. Which of course has left me feeling I should translate “justwanna” and its cognates as “Lord, we f*****ng want to praise you….”
tortoise 09.01.10 at 3:01 pm
Justwanna prayers always bring out my inner Harry Enfield:
http://www.youtube.com/watch?v=Bwk38srACrA
Kim 09.01.10 at 3:41 pm
Now that, Tony, would be something to see/hear at a CU prayer meeting: “Father, it’s f*****g good to be here, to praise our a***s off and to pray for the god***n people who don’t know you as Saviour and Lord…”! Still, I’m not sure your explanation is adequate to the phenomenon. With the prisoners, I suspect that’s just the way they talk (and, btw, with Hauerwas, the way I often talk too!). And with the Justwanna People, the phrase is too universal just to be a verbal breather; it has, I think, semeiotic significance. “You know” would actually be an interesting substitute - not least because it is accurate!
Btw, do you know Reading the Bible with the Damned (2005) by Bob Ekblad? Ekblad is a US Presbyterian minister who has worked widely and deeply with “people on the margins”, including the hardened incarcerated. The book is a record of no-bullshit Bible studies with these socially, not divinely, “damned”. I’m sure the book would resonate with you with your own prison experiences.
Rick O'Donnell 09.03.10 at 3:08 am
Kim, I justwanna say, y’know, well like, I justwanna build on what the previous wannaprayer said, y’know? Sorta like what he said, but kinda like out of my mouth, instead of his…is that OK? Whew, that was, like, really hard!
Kim 09.03.10 at 8:55 am
I know wha yah mean, Rick, yah know wha I mean? Like?
Wood 09.08.10 at 9:16 am
I am glad it’s not just me who finds it stupid and ungrammatical.
You don’t “just want to” praise God. You praise God. You confess, you ask. You don’t distance yourself from the action.